Guild Challenges

[XxSwAtRaNgErXx]

Another Suggestion.
Basically Hearing That The Guild Vs Guild Will Make Lag Ect. I Decide To Chat To
Other Members In Chat Hearing Their Suggestions And Here Is A Really Cool Suggestion :)

Guilds Can Apply For Guild Challenges Same As Adventures OR Clearing Your Island,Just With A Bigger Amount Of Soldiers And Income.When You Go And Apply For A Challenge You Can Pick (Who Can Attend) And Then The Members Pick What Units They Want To Use.Every Guild Will Get A Challenge Map Where They Can Battle Of The Evil Bandits And Get Good Amount Of Income.

Here Is A Example:

I Have A Clan With 100 Members All Of Them Have Level 50s,I Pick 5 Of Them For The Guild Challenge.They Go Pick There Units And We Start A War With Around 60k Soldiers We Win The Battle And Lose 30k Soldiers But We Get Lots Of ::guild:: ::bread:: ::fish:: And Other Stuff.After Completing All Of The Challenges You Get A Special Reward.

Email After The Battle:
You have completed the following bandit camp and get the income of:
::guild:: ::bread:: ::fish:: ::cannon:: ::coins:: ::hardwoodplanks:: ::marble:: ::gem::
1000 1000 1000 2 1000 1000 1000 1

You have also gained 10::xp:: levels for a victorious Battle

Please Do Comment What You Think And Give Improvements!!
(Open For Improvements)

Regards,
Ranger

[Salem_Warrior_1]

looks very good m8..gr8 work

[XxSwAtRaNgErXx]

Thanks!!!

[Dragon-Lord79]

brill Suggestion. will be gd having guilds work as team on adventures no water what level mysef personal im lvl 50 would love to be able to take some lower lvl ppl help them with weapeons bread brew then work as a team to do a large adventure so t6hey can get loads of gd rewards

[Gal-the-Usurper]

Sounds like the sort of thing the game needs. Adv are good but not enough and promoting Guild V Guild Team games will be great for the game and the guilds.

[PrincessAlly]

Nice idea. Would be good to have a guild challenge that is co-operative and can involve both high and low level players

[M-Z-A]

This sounds great. Especially when guild bank is implemented and the prizes could go direct in there.

[kevg]

sounds like a good idea. it could bring all levels together on an even ground if working as a co-operative :-)

[davec25]

great would be good fun and could help lower level players

[Lorja]

I think it works for both - people who are lvl 50 and those striving to get there - great to hear of an adventure where co-operation within your guild has a definite advantage to everyone.

[Shonsu]

Nice idea... A new angle to the game would be good...

[psy1]

+1

[Swanvesta]

i think this is a good idea..

i'd suggest something a little different, like making the challenge harder, so that it really did require a significant amount of a guild to complete a map/adv give large rewards, but have rankings based on who kills the most units in guild adventures, who clears the most adventures etc etc.. would invigorate the top end of the game somewhat for sure, and slowly bring in the competitive edge this game is lacking

[richvette]

awsome idea,we need to get a heap of people behind this and really push BB along :)

[Atarah]

fantastic idea:)

[MarkG]

sounds like a good idea, so... wont be implemented by BB

[DoctorScientist]

Have a map whereby each Guild Member can only bring 1 general. The very concept of "cooperative blocking" would be hilarious to coordinate.

[Andriana78]

good idea :)

[Jules65]

Great idea! Sounds like fun.

[MuffinMule]

No thanks, until the Guild Quests stop demanding to do adv after adv after adv, not going to have time or inclination.

[Nogbad]

Not interested.
If you'd played this more than 2 weeks, you might see why the game works as it stands. Don't know why people keep coming in trying to change it to some kind of PvP game, seen it happen before and they never stick around long.
Who is going to supply the rewards for this, because I can bet your bottom dollar it won't be BB? Not in their interest. Even if by some miracle they did, system would need a complete overhaul to distribute the goods alone, let alone provide yet another server draining arena when Flash is already making this creak at the seams.
Already needs an overhaul now, just to accommodate the stuff that got loose from test before it was ready or working.
Seriously, play the game for a while first, instead of trying to change it to something else which is already covered many times over elsewhere.
If you want to see just how bad this can go, take a look at Forge of Empires and the awful update 1.20 that brought in GvG. Destroyed the whole game overnight.

[Dragon-Lord79]

ive been playing for 2 years im lvl 50 done every adventure its not pvp its doing adventure where u have to work as a guild team to take camps out

[lumaro]

Very interesting. I think it's a very good idea. :-)

[XxSwAtRaNgErXx]

Suggestion Box Added:
Ranking Is Based On How Much Who Clears The Most Adventures

When You Win A Battle Against The Bandits You Get A High Amount Of Income To Your Bank Something like 10k and some gems.

Thanks To Swanvesta.
This Is Not Also For Level 50 Players,What You Only Need Is Tactics And Army!

[XxSwAtRaNgErXx]

Not interested.
If you'd played this more than 2 weeks, you might see why the game works as it stands. Don't know why people keep coming in trying to change it to some kind of PvP game, seen it happen before and they never stick around long.
Who is going to supply the rewards for this, because I can bet your bottom dollar it won't be BB? Not in their interest. Even if by some miracle they did, system would need a complete overhaul to distribute the goods alone, let alone provide yet another server draining arena when Flash is already making this creak at the seams.
Already needs an overhaul now, just to accommodate the stuff that got loose from test before it was ready or working.
Seriously, play the game for a while first, instead of trying to change it to something else which is already covered many times over elsewhere.
If you want to see just how bad this can go, take a look at Forge of Empires and the awful update 1.20 that brought in GvG. Destroyed the whole game overnight.
Well It's Not Exactly, PVP (Player Vs Player) But Guild Challenges Is A Adventure Where Its Much More Harder And A Good Amount Of Income To The Guild.Plus We Already Have A Adventure System.

[SimonSays22]

New thing - sound always good to me :)

[Tina11]

sounds like a good idea, and a great way to get new players within a guild to see how adv's work.

[Dorotheus]

While the fundimental idea behind this suggestion is intresting, it needs to be fleshed out by experiance gained by playing the game for more than 5 minites. What defines a easy or hard camp depends on your player level. A low level player may struggle to take out a camp with several attacks where a higher level player will be taking out several camps at once without any troop losses.

[Haggarth]

Plus one from me...

Guild challenges, team work, and any other techiques that makes the team working all together, are always wellcome!

Makes the game interesting ;)

[popi27]

great idea....something new, interesting....can't wait!!!

[KingRob]

All in :)

[Thejollyone]

love the idea, and suggested it in a previous post not so long ago in the broadest of senses, but just so disillusioned with BB atm I cant ever see it happening :(

[Salem_Warrior_1]

@ jolly . i hear you and hope BB does for once
the game is boring at higher lv's. although alot of us try to mentor and help the lower lv's progress ect..this will put us all together and make game more interesting for all of us..
BB pls listen to us. we love this game and need a little more

[G4meOver]

great idear, a lot of the higher lvl players are getting bored with the game, something like this will put the fun back into the game alittle!

[imyourmum]

+1 nice idea :)

[bloodybutcher]

what a good idea! it gets the thumbs up from me

[Jim_B]

put it on the German forum - someone from BB might even read it then

[Salem_Warrior_1]

gr8 idear jim, it will be if we get enoth feed back to present a good case

[Wanderer-nl]

Can't read it when every first letter of every word is capitalized. I hate to be whining about spelling/grammar, but seriously is this necessary?

[imyourmum]

Can't read it when every first letter of every word is capitalized. I hate to be whining about spelling/grammar, but seriously is this necessary?

WeII I Hope My Post Dont Get U Angry Wont Wanna 0FFend You I Pratice My Grammer aII The Time Some Times In a Dark Room :p

[XxSwAtRaNgErXx]

Sure Thing.I Will Do It.

[Thejollyone]

prntscr.com/31p9hn Note the "Rules and code of conduct / beginners guide / Important Links / Help and Support & FAQs" under this "noob's" post?

Im sorry, but a bit more transparency would be in order rather than posing as a new player. Theres no denying that this is a good idea, but Im pretty disgusted with all this under-handedness. Shame on you for trying to fool your dedicated player-base in this manner. I dont doubt for one minute this post will last any longer than 3 minutes before its removed, so I have screen shot it for later use.

[Jim_B]

must be BB - only BB would suggest winning 1 gem and 2 cannons for losing 30k soldiers

[Dragon-Lord79]

does not mean they bb king-rob is in my guild he has something under his name to and he definatly not bb and the rewards was just to show a example

[Jim_B]

the rewards was just to show a example
ermm… joke? nevermind.

[Baggis]

I'm confused - how is this suggestion any different from a renamed Co-op adventures which are due to be released very soon anyway? Co-op adventures: an adventure map which you choose X number of players to complete the map with, each person having to do their own slice and then a final reward divided up. What does your suggestion bring over and above that? Some vague challenge to compete against other guilds in the process, but how?

"Every Guild Will Get A Challenge Map Where They Can Battle Of The Evil Bandits And Get Good Amount Of Income"

Are you proposing linking numerous separate co-op adventures together? If so to what result? Which guild clears their island first wins?? Many replies say +1 to this but I really can't see any coherent suggestion here.

[Jim_B]

I am surprised everyone seems to have missed this bit

...Basically Hearing That The Guild Vs Guild Will Make Lag Ect...
Where did you hear this? guild vs guild or PvP? what is this referring to? This isn't something I hear discussed amongst other long term players, so where did you get this 'fact'?

[Dragon-Lord79]

baggis the idea was say like that a camp needs to have eg 5 seperate attacks but 1 player can only do 1 of the attacks on each given camp and guild locked so few ppl work in guild as a team to clear the adventure

[Salem_Warrior_1]

All in all this is a gr8 idear.. a guild multi player adventure, with different strength camps so all lower and higher lv members can attack..it will liven up chat
the whole idear of it being limited to the guild is for the sole reason of a multi player adventure outside the guilds would require a separate chat channel. not possible, with the current chat channel set up.
the rewards are a suggestion only and ofc will be set by the DEVs if they take up this idear
Anything extra and more in this game is welcomed and so needed, as for alot of experienced players the games become stale
pls leave any suggestions you may have to how we may improve this or indeed any thoughts at all

[Bluesavanah]

I like the idea and anything that would add content would be awesome, only reservation I'd have would be it might favour large guilds in recruitment etc. I saw a very similar thing happen in GW2 and it nearly decimated small guilds.

[XxSwAtRaNgErXx]

This Suggestion Tries To Involve Everyone In A Active Guild But Just A Little Challenge And Rewards

[Dragon-Lord79]

bluesavanh not if they make it say 5 player then would not make a diffrence on the size of guild

[Jim_B]

5 players? then it's just one more than a co-op adventure?

[Dragon-Lord79]

was just example but yes co-op like

[Sharpielein]

Yeah, the game just needs a lot more time consuming resource drains with no adequate reward.

At least it should have some rewards which are both:
a) Not causing inflation of certain goods.
b) Sufficiently interesting to actually engage.

Next step:
Not everyone is in a guild with 100 lv50's spending time 24/7 to play Settlers.
I have absolutely no idea how you want to balance something which is sufficiently interesting for lv50's and 30's alike - and sufficiently challenging for casuals who can barely maintain their island and progamers alike ...
Maybe noncombat challanges?

But no thanks I don't need more adventures.
I'm already sufficiently busy with my usual undertakings and the "mandatory" adventures per week showing up in my "Daily/Guild quest" log. (refer to "No adventures on GQ" thread for more info).

[Salem_Warrior_1]

yes a co-op adventure withing a guild , as said in the description..id say 5-10 would players would be reasable..but that up to the devs.. if they decided to take this idear up
and i would present this to the davs as an optional extra adventure , definatly not tied to any GQ's..cos i dont do them, waist of resorces and a drain on a player,and a chore, that makes the game bad

[Drethwene]

Test post