Juggernaut vs First Aid on Major

[numa]

Hi everyone!

I was wondering did someone try to compare the losses that you get with Major when using Juggernaut vs First Aid? My question is actually which one of these saves more troops...

Thanks!

[Ma_Baker]

First aid better. definitely.

[Bluesavanah]

I took first aid saves loads of troops, to me juggernaut is weak and not much more than a filler skill on most gens to reach 3rd row. I had to put 1 book in it because I wasn't picking up Navigation crash course.

[numa]

Thanks for your input guys. I hope that more people will share their opinions. So splash damage doesn't do much on the Major?

[EasyTarget1]

Done some sims on vlt sector 1 leader with jugger, 10 rounds not a jot of difference. One use I have seen for this skill is to add 1 lvl to Drac or MoD so they can make a kill on closest camp in vlt. Otherwise just a filler.

[Dorotheus]

Juggernaut is only worth having if the fight lasts a lot of rounds, Typically the sorts of attacks done with the Major last only 1 or 2 rounds therefore Juggernaut will not make much of a difference if at all.

[DaisyDuke]

well this is a no-brainer

[numa]

Juggernaut is only worth having if the fight lasts a lot of rounds, Typically the sorts of attacks done with the Major last only 1 or 2 rounds therefore Juggernaut will not make much of a difference if at all.

Do you think that Battle Frenzy is also not appropriate for the Major (since this skill gains power with the number of rounds)?

[HFoC]

it is indeed overrated.

[EasyTarget1]

Depends on the battle I think. If you block the sector 1 leader on vlt battle frenzy works well. Same on first thief, prolly more ali's that take a few rounds.

[BB_Saqui]

I really like First Aid personally. And yeah I agree with EasyTarget - how useful Battle Frenzy is subject to the adventure.