Members in guilds stays on forever and that feels bad.
What if a guild member that havent played for 8-10 weeks would be kicked out off guild?
Many guild would be much smaller but all guild would be alive and they can always ask to be admitted again
Printable View
Members in guilds stays on forever and that feels bad.
What if a guild member that havent played for 8-10 weeks would be kicked out off guild?
Many guild would be much smaller but all guild would be alive and they can always ask to be admitted again
The decision to keep long term inactive players is made by the guild leadership. Long term inactives do not have any effect on the guild quests and are not even counted in the calculation for how many active members needed to complete it. The only problem they can cause is taking up slots for potential new members. If the leadership is not freeing up slots for new members then they are not doing their job and I for one would start looking for a better lead guild.
They do have an effect on the amount of rewards the quest gives.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dorotheus
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fexno
Yup, we only have about 12-14 actives each quest (except during events) and still get 17+119.Quote:
Originally Posted by Durin_d
It is a good idea to keep inactives until spaces needed for new recruits.
this is exactly why they should be automatly kicked out
no auto kick would ruïne guilds, like what if someone had an accident or got sick, what if a member is on vacation, or is busy with school and made a agreement with the leader...???Quote:
Originally Posted by AnnL
a guild is lead by 1 person, that 1 person decides what to do and what the guild is like...
if he doesnt handle those things in guild its his problem... and if you dont like it you can search a new/better one.
so -1 to this idea
We need a better reason why after 24 hours the game kicks you out of a guild than you just stating thats the way you want it.Quote:
Originally Posted by AnnL
24 hours?
i think 100 days or something
Just curious but how would this add to your game play ?
24 hours because thats how long before you are shown as being inactive in the members tab.Quote:
Originally Posted by AnnL
That's not the only time frame about inactivity..Quote:
Originally Posted by Dorotheus
Though, I think changes suggested by OP are rather blunt solutions to issues better solved in other ways..Quote:
Originally Posted by BB_Alpaca
Like..Then there would be less reasons to keep inactive players in a guild.
- Add filter and search options in the list of guilds.
- Only count active members when setting up to give and reward GQ.
24 hours is way too short. It's not fair to expect a player to log in every single day without fail. Life doesn't work that way, things happen. Some people can't play that often for many reasons.
No one is suggestion that you're replying to.Quote:
Originally Posted by Xibor
Wish they gave guild leaders the tools to see the progress on the guild members and see who's been active or not. Then it's for guild leaders and officers to decide what to do with it. Atm we are at the maximum of members, and there's no way we can export or have any data at all. The current information is not enough to build cases on, and the member GQ status is not exportable.
Make it better to monitor or remove the member cap, so it becomes less important who's active or not
In our guild anyone who fails to complete GQ on two successive occasions is demoted to part-time player. If you are on the part-timer list for 21 consecutive days without contacting a guild officer with an explanation ( illness/holiday etc) you are booted. When we boot we sand a mail with a copy of our guild rules and say that if there was a genuine reason for not being active for 21 days to get in touch and let us know and we will re-consider.