is there anywhere to give feedback on the items in each guild vote? The latest lot are shockingly awful!
is there anywhere to give feedback on the items in each guild vote? The latest lot are shockingly awful!
but its awesome that we have 30.06% trolls in the community
Was fighting windmills from Aug 2012 to Oct 2019.
Did anyone find something in the second part worth voting for? I didnt.
nor the first partOriginally Posted by SSSecretSquirrel
wont vote this time around nothing worth voting on
Agree with hades8840, not worth my time voting, but I do want to know why put a watermill and an improved watermill in the same category for one vote ? Which bright spark at BB came up with that? All that development time for this new system and a lack of thought in the content just makes you look like a bunch of lemons !!
We were discussing guild quests and there value in chat the other night. Well with this offering I repeat my stance, are all those resources, all those addies and all that time and effort to do those guild quests really worth this?
I'm voting `None of the above' to make a point BB don't read it any other way.
Are we to be told of adventure changes or not? 1 Month on and still SNEAKY RB changes have not been mentioned
I also had to really shake my head on this list to vote from. Improved Watermill and regular Watermill at the same time? I fail to see how that makes any sense. And the second group I would only describe as being pathetic. Cheese Sandwich? Seriously?
I think the choices for the 2nd group should be much lager (e.g. many more options) so at least there is a chance there's something to chose from that I think would be liked. I think these were selected with a classic 'dartboard' approach - I can't figure it any other way.
Sorry, but I've slept since then...
to give slightly more detailed feedback as .. this seems to be where we are responding to this latest disappointment.....
The first choices ...
arctic mine .... not really useful before the latest easter event due to industrial iron mine ... now with iron willed geo just having been launched .. you get more iron ore by letting mines run down and finding them again.. which also takes next to no time with iron willed geo so this is a complete waste unless you cant get many eggs from event.
Watermill .. been in game so long now you can hardly give them away also they are in the current event. why offer watermill and IMPROVED at same time? also price difference between the 2 means normal watermill really shouldnt be being picked by anyone.
IMPROVED watermill .. the best of a bad selection in my opinion but again due to length of time in game most players already have loads and getting them via trade is easy and cheap for newer players due to high supply as they have been around so long.
Of the second tier to choose from .... oh dear.... truly awful.
Horseback and Black Knights - on offer anyway for map parts which are cheaper. So utterly pointless being offered here. Anyone who wants those adventures can simply go to adventure shop already to get them. If they dont have map parts any active guild will have members willing to give some map parts away anyone without access to this .. is in the wrong guild or not in a guild which .. defeats the point of having them in guild shop vote in the first place.
Tropical Sun - the fastest lowest loss adventure on offer .. to help people with a GQ requiring a new adventure to be completed and they need something quick and simple .. not as easy as grains.twins but .. hey ho..... but the alternative witch of the swamp is in adventure shop anyway .. this doesnt really offer a much better alternative.
Zombie buff - an option to assist on guild quests/quests/production for production quests... but across the entire shop .. this is provbably the only item even vaguely worth voting for ... and its hardly an exciting option.... far better buffs and equally good buffs available in quantity and cheaply.
Zombie bite - total fluff
Cheese Sandwich - probably the most useless buff in game.
Iron refill - expoensive - new iron willed geo makes this pointless you are better off using those geos to get the extra iron ore they find in deposits and they are fast at finding it.
Marble refill - even using a slow geo is fairly quick to find fresh deposits ... pointless.
Stone refill - at worst it takes 2 minutes to find a fresh stone deposit .... so why waste ggc on this?
in summary .. there is NOTHING here to attract any player of any level. ALL options are appalling.
Would like to see ......
1) more frequent changes - even if there isnt time for some players to save for the best new item it might come round again or ggc market gets a boost or it makes people think about saving for something better in next shop.
2) A specialist amongst the options a little more often .. extra explorers/geos/gens. Also really helps out newer players having more frequent access to a fast gen from time to time even if its "just" a bhg.
3) NOT having 2 of the same building type being offered at same time .. like watermill/improved watermill this time.
4) One of twins/grain conflict/heart of wood always offered as a fast option for people looking for something quick and easy for "complete a new adventure" in their guild quests.
5) never having adventures offered which are already in adventure shop for map parts.
6) some more useful buffs always being offered eg bookbinder buff/barazek/rainbow snow/oil can/elixir/medikit/stadium snack/rabbit foot/nash williams/chant of focus/ ....
7) refills if being made available for deposits that take a long time to search for .. and aren't affected by many specialist skills .. eg granite/salt/tit/gold ore.
8) some real choices and more choices - where you really need to think between a selection of items for whats best at all levels rather than being offered a choice .. where very little/nothing is very appealing.
9) Consider adding some of the lower level excelsior adventures/guides to options
10) Use guild shop as an option for buying upcoming seasonal adventures for next event (even if you don't tell us thats what you have done)
I have to agree with most of the points raised here about the latest offering for voting upon, particularly the (lack of) thinking behind putting regular and improved Watermills against one another as well as choice of the Cheese Sandwich. There is one point made I would speak to, however:
Putting the issue of price to one side for a moment, given the appearance of Lost Skull, Dark Priests and Secluded Experiments in the vote that recently closed (all of which are seasonal at the moment) and the fact that Horseback, Arctic Explosion, Tropical Sun and Dark Brotherhood are in the current voting choices (each of which are potential candidates for being Seasonal in the near future), it is quite conceivable that they are already doing this without telling us.
Now, if they could set the prices at a realistic level then we might actually get somewhere. 200ggc for a Tropical Sun or Lost Skull is not great, but when you consider that the only other way to get them is Adventure searches, then it's not that bad a price, compared to some.
However, 870ggc for an Arctic Explosion and even 300ggc for a Horseback are too expensive... and don't get me started on how ridiculous the prices set for Dark Brotherhood and Secluded Experiments have been!
Can't help agreeing with Larili:
Last edited by Madorosu; 06.04.18 at 12:58.
guild coins
Last edited by Qaw-Paw; 07.04.18 at 07:40.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote