[Feedback] [Dev Diary] Guild Fest

[Urd123]

Well, you should get them. If you have guild of 100 members, and you all finish the Guild Quest, you get 284gc daily. You need only 1479 days to acquire that amount. That is only 4 years.
Or simpler. You need to do Guild Quest with 99 other members of the guild twice in order to buy a buff that lasts 1 hour as friend buff.

My guild have 22 members I did not read anywhere that this event was for 100 member guilds only

[Urd123]

That would be the end of guilds. Every player that is above guild average has better chance alone. Or if there is the minimum (ie. 5 members), then top (5) players would abandon the guild and found their own. And players like myself and few other (top) players in my guild should be kicked out since we have problems logging in.

Why - no rule says that a guild needs to have 100 members. But if you are to compare the guilds in a guild fest - you cant use total tokens donated. You can have a guild ad play at the level you please - but if you are not active during an event like this - then your guild suffers- that does not mean that you have to close the guild,

[First_Lord]

Urd and others, dont ask for new stuff, dont post ideas, those ... cannot program anything new w/out bugs, average bug sorting time is well over year.
yes, I`m screeeming:
NOTHING CRAPPY NEW UNTIL YOU FIX STUFF, CODE AND SERVERS ALIKE!!!!!!!!!!!

And ofc, first attempt to post this failed, due to some error.

[Urd123]

Strange things happens in this game. The log in issues - the time outs ..
and now this :-D
https://prnt.sc/AvLIJ3e55HmQ
Guild fest grounds producing buffs for the twins

[First_Lord]

Bugged, Doro on Sandy just said in chat, his offers oil production. Prob. not working.

Edit: it offers production of last of cultural/PH you visited, but if you try to enable, at least mine crashed game.

[Cylancer]

Why - no rule says that a guild needs to have 100 members. But if you are to compare the guilds in a guild fest - you cant use total tokens donated. You can have a guild ad play at the level you please - but if you are not active during an event like this - then your guild suffers- that does not mean that you have to close the guild,

Neither did I. But if more players finish guild quest, they get more coins each, up to 100.

I think I have to explain better. If you use average instead of total. Guild that has only 5 players and all of them are active would rank higher than guild of 100 with 50 active players. So, if you are in a guild that has inactive players, you leave and start a new guild with minimum number of players. Even 1 inactive player in guild of 100 would lower them below a guild with minimum number of active players.

[Urd123]

Why would people leave a god functioning guild for 1 event? - Besides you need 8 guild members to be able to get guild coins,- you can also make a limit for how many you need to be to take part in the guild fest. You could fine some compromise on how to calculatem or just have different categories that compete.
say
10- 25
25-40
40- 65
65- 100

just an example I am sure someone can figure out a way to make it more fair, than have a 20 member guild compete with a 100 member guild for total number of tokens.

[JohnRo79]

too many guilds might be more stress on the hamster

this event cleared off a lot of STAR stuff.
in the future, maybe they'll clear off dead wood too , for a smoother experience for the ones who stayed in it so far

all together, every event has crap performance, technically speaking.

[Qualan]

Why would people leave a god functioning guild for 1 event? - Besides you need 8 guild members to be able to get guild coins,- you can also make a limit for how many you need to be to take part in the guild fest. You could fine some compromise on how to calculatem or just have different categories that compete.
say
10- 25
25-40
40- 65
65- 100

just an example I am sure someone can figure out a way to make it more fair, than have a 20 member guild compete with a 100 member guild for total number of tokens.

shrug, depends on definitions of fair

I can see hard core number 1 wannabee's doing exactly that - join forces for event to max out on average participation/points per person if you can do this with limited amount of guildmembers -

Of course, you have to wonder how it would go down with the previous guildies that you bail to get a prize and then return for social guild stuff

As soon as you go on averages and such, u get guilds that will also ruthlessly cull low participation/inactives

So any scenario that sets guild against guild will have unwanted side effects, esp with a game on the decline when this might drive more people away from the game

[JohnRo79]

well, well, well done BB
your master planning broke my gem streak . thanks a lot