Thank you I feel better For me the most important thing is that players do enjoy playing the game and staying within it whatever server , whether in a guild or not is their choice. I do understand about the shortage of time and real life is definitely more important. The only thing we have asked our members not to do is the knee jerk 'i must leave for the good of the guild, I am unable to do my part' as the most important thing for us are not the guild quests but the social side. A good chat with someone once a week is 'like striking gold' and if they slip in and out without doing guild quests and no time to speak no worries. All are here to enjoy the game or have some relief from real life issues.
I am currently still analysing the quests and how they affect each member that wants to do them and there is still not a full list. But even just doing 3 a week should bring in more guild coins than before for us and if this is not the case throughout the guild sizes then BB should address that to make it fairer.