That's it here for me for some time. I lost interest several weeks ago when I was unable to defeat Chuck, but kept plodding on and having a go at him when I got sufficient cavalry. After countless attacks and losses decided that the was no way I was going to do it with 2 general so invested in a third. Having killed all the dogs and got down to 80 roughnecks I felt I was bound to do it now.
I've just lost 152 cavalry, over 300 recruits 50 militia over 50 bowmen, still not managed to kill him and there are still 67 roughneck left. This is just getting bl**dy pointless.
Every single combination I've tried on both battle calculators tell me there is no sure way to win