Guild Quest Rewards: Guild Coins vs Event Resources during events

[topgearfan]

They could do time or count locked purchases but that would just be needles work if they would be limited.

But it does mean that players can choose..

[Muttleyazc]

Both would be nice

[Kanhai]

Absolutely NOT!!! The trade office prices always go out of Whack during Events, We don't need to further destabilize things by a. removing the main source of gc, and b. Giving an even MORE unfair advantage to people who are playing in the guild system over people who play outside the guild system. The Game shouldn't reward some players over others because they have a preference of play style.

I agree with Greatdane247, some event res. should be available in the guild market during events. It would cover more ground, or at least give ppl the ability to get event items they want now that they can't outright buy using stockpiles.

[Nogbad]

Trade office prices are always out of whack.

[cagee]

wish we could choose the reward, i would like to get more star coins instead of either of the guild coins or event resources

[andreaus]

hi
I'm new only been playing a few weeks but I'm not in a guild yet, I have just left a game I was playing for 2 yrs and was very active in their forum so I always like to add input, I have to add I really enjoyed the chrismas event I joined at the right time and it also enabled me to have a great start to the game by selling presents to build up my resources, if it is a guild event then guild coins would be the way to go (but I can't speak for guild players) but if its a grid wide event for all players then it should be resources as I wouldn't really have any benefit from playing the event I love events and the rewards from you for the Christmas event were far better than any rewards I got from the old game I played I was really impressed with the items and the amounts you gave us it wasn't just one or two it was a lot more, it is really nice to play a game where the developers appreciate the effort and time us players put in to their game, I would like to vote for resources and maybe special buildings

[Bluesavanah]

Dear Settlers,

In the light of the feedback in this thread, we would like to clarify some aspects of this survey.

The poll is about what you would prefer to see in the game, the exact balancing of this potential change has not been decided yet. If you like the idea of getting varied rewards depending on current events, then you have the opportunity to let the Game Design team know! We will then look into how everything can be balanced and made fair to everyone.

Please also keep in mind that any potential changes to the rewards will not affect the current Guild Quest system: any changes will be made after the Guild Quest Rework.

Happy Voting!
BB_Ravel

I've used BB's current conversion rate of 3 ggc to 1 gem and 3 gems to 1 present using the merchant as a guide. Using the proposed payout table for the new guild quests in the sneak peek.

Assuming everyone does the Guild Quest

10 man guild - 8 presents per daily quest
50 man guild - 20 presents per daily quest
99 man guild - 29 presents per daily quest
not in a guild - 0

I've no idea if the ratio of 3ggc to 1 gem remains the same under the new payout system so this is hypothetical but I'm really struggling to see how this is going to be fair to everyone, there is possibly a massive disparity between small and large guild let alone those not in a guild.

[scaree]

I agree, like the star/warehouse option

[pauantbro]

Eggs or Presents might encourage more people to complete quests, although those not in a guild are significantly disadvantaged.

+1
If this proposed idea is implemented, i personally would prefer having the option to choose :-)

[jabbathehutt01]

guild coins for guild quests event quest for event currency

it been working for ages no need to change it now